This post contains affiliate links, which means I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for using my links!
If you enjoy the traditional way of making things (like cooking or crafting), than making soap might be your next adventure. Soapmaking is a fascinating craft that allows for creativity and the satisfaction of making something useful from scratch. There are two main methods to make soap at home: hot process and cold process. Each method has its own unique characteristics, benefits, and challenges. Let's look at the pros and cons of each:
Cold Process Soapmaking
Cold process soapmaking is often considered the more traditional method. Here, oils (like olive, coconut, palm) and a lye solution (distilled water and lye) are mixed together at temperatures anywhere between 80° to 105°. The chemical reaction of the lye turns the mixture into soap; this is known as saponification and begins almost immediately. This method requires patience, as the soap needs to cure (meaning the water and lye needs to dissapate) for about four to six weeks after it's poured into molds.
Benefits of Cold Process Soap:
Customization: You can create intricate designs and swirls because the batter stays fluid longer.
Texture and Feel: Cold process soap typically has a smoother texture and can feel more luxurious.
Ingredient Control: You have complete control over the ingredients, allowing for natural, additive-free soap.
Scent Retention: Essential oils and fragrances tend to last longer because they are not exposed to high heat. Using Kaolin Clay also helps to anchor the scent.
Challenges of Cold Process Soap:
Time-Consuming: The long curing time means you need to plan well in advance.
Lye Handling: Working with lye can be dangerous if not handled properly. You must learn all about lye safety and the gear required.
Batch Variability: Sometimes the final product can vary due to the natural ingredients and process.
Hot Process Soapmaking
Hot process soapmaking, on the other hand, speeds up the saponification (curing) process by using heat. After the oils and lye solution are mixed, the mixture is heated (often in a slow cooker or double boiler). This method involves cooking the soap mixture until it becomes thick and gel-like. Once the cooking is complete, the soap can be spooned into molds and is ready to use as soon as it hardens, although two weeks of curing can improve its quality.
Benefits of Hot Process Soap:
Faster Results: Soap is ready to use much sooner, often within a few days.
Rustic Appearance: The texture is more rustic and natural-looking, which many people find appealing.
Scent and Additives: You can add essential oils and other additives after the cooking process, reducing the risk of them degrading.
Reliable Outcome: The cooking ensures complete saponification, leading to fewer surprises.
Challenges of Hot Process Soap:
Limited Design Options: The thick, mash potato-like consistency makes it difficult to create detailed designs or swirls.
Less Smooth Texture: Hot process soap can have a rougher texture compared to cold process soap.
Extra Equipment: You’ll need a slow cooker or another heat source, which might require additional investment. If using a slow cooker or crockpot, make sure to buy the "dial" kind with a high and low setting instead of a programmable one. It will make things easier.
BUY YOUR COCKPOT HERE!
Choosing Between Hot and Cold Process
Choosing between hot and cold process soapmaking depends on your priorities. If you value intricate designs and are willing to wait, cold process might be your best bet. On the other hand, if you’re eager to use your soap quickly and enjoy a more rustic look, hot process could be the way to go.
Tips for Both Methods
Regardless of the method you choose, safety is paramount. Always wear gloves and goggles when handling lye, and work in a well-ventilated area. Measure your ingredients precisely and follow your recipe closely to ensure a successful batch. Watch lots of Youtube videos from experienced soapmakers that teach the basics one or the other processes.
Author's Note: For me, I love the cold process method. After experimenting with melt and pour soap bases for a year, I summoned the courage to try my hand at cold process. Once I tried it, it felt as though I had been making soap my whole life. I have also tried hot process and feel it's a good idea to feel comfortable making both hot/cold methods as hot process can come in handy in a "need-soap-now" emergency.